We’ve got “immigration” all wrong
I’m not an “open borders” libertarian. And borderless anarchy isn’t possible with humans (see I Samuel 8:6-20). So at least for some degree of control over communicable disease (we’ve been lucky so far), human trafficking, etc., we need to have some border security. If you allow that you’ve got a political government, and other states/nations have theirs as well, there have to be borders and jurisdictional limits to politicians’ rules. And I’m more about actual law and order than 99.999873% of the planet.
So don’t get me wrong.
But our current problems aren’t with illegal aliens, immigrants, or any of the laws and policies thereof.
- We are luring illegal aliens here with free stuff. Free healthcare. Free education. Special rights, privileges and immunities unavailable to even legal citizens. There are lots of reasons why we’re doing it…but I propose we stop doing this.
- We’ve made “legal” labor so expensive, complicated, legalistic and impractical that “illegal” labor is a very attractive option, or sometimes the only workable option. I propose we reverse this.
- We’ve been tormenting and destroying other nations with our “War On Drugs”, CIA crime rings and coups, oppressive policies/embargoes and direct attacks, such that We The People have, both directly and indirectly, made some $#!+holes that don’t need to be $#!+holes. In other words, we’ve made other people’s countries practically uninhabitable, driving them here for survival. I propose we stop doing all this.
- Our ever-changing, unpredictable and absurdly unfair immigration laws and policies force illegal aliens to lay low, force employers to keep secrets and break laws, and generally force the realities of illegal aliens under the rug. I propose we make our immigration laws and policies fair, consistent, and focused on our domestic security, health and interests…and then just enforce them!
- Do you know how hard it is for potential immigrants to get visas? Pretty much impossible. So smugglers make a great business getting tens of thousands of dollars for every person they get to the border illegally. But if it were easier/possible to get visas, then the sort of people we want here, the ones who’re desperately wanting to build a better life for themselves and their loved ones, could hop a plane for tens of thousands less, go through controlled checkpoints with drug sniffing dogs and people wearing blue gloves, and go legit. I propose we make it much easier and cheaper to come here the right way. That’d welcome the good folks and put the squeeze on only the bad ones.
- There actually is, since the 14th Amendment, a constitutional stipulation that anyone born in the USA is automatically a USA citizen. “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” So, really, there’s a powerful incentive for pregnant women to dive over the national goal posts to deliver a baby in the citizen end-zone. It’s not their fault if they succeed. However… Think about how the rules of monitoring “documented” citizens and trans-border “security” would be enforced. Given the sort of nazi/commies we continuously re-elect, this could get really ugly. “Your papers please” is already a problem. Spying on us all is already a thing.
- Besides…if you know you live in a $#!+hole, can’t make it better, and want a better life for you and your loved ones, you’d be a fool not to find a way here, where you’ll find life better than you’ve ever known. Right? Wouldn’t you do the same?
The first four bullets above exist only in breach of the federal constitution. In other words, those problems would be solved if all we did was affirm and enforce the Constitution for The United States of America against our government.
In other words, if we’d just quit making “legal” labor so costly, quit making illegal entry the only door, quit giving away freebies to illegal aliens, and stop messing up other countries, we’d not likely even talk about a wall.
In fact if we were to just DO the constitutions, state and federal, as written and amended, we’d not likely be constantly fiddling with our immigration laws, and we might even legally, legitimately welcome people looking for a better life as our friends, coworkers and neighbors.
While The US of A is no longer the freest, wealthiest or healthiest nation on earth, we are among the most accommodating to foreigners.
Is that really a bad thing? We can discuss that.
Of course, if you’re one of those “‘Merica – Love it or Leave it!” people, you’ve got a little ‘splaining to do…
Sure, there are the “Reconquistas,” the criminals, the terrorists. But their numbers are tiny compared to the home-grown murderers, rapists and thieves (even outside the DC beltway); and their numbers are tiny compared to the regular human beings trying to do better for themselves and their loved ones. They didn’t love what became of their country, and they left it.
The discussion we’ve been having over illegal aliens in major media and political discussions is stupid. We play word games, divide ourselves against ourselves, and place blame and propose punishment for our screw-ups on people who’re doing the best they can to get by in a world gone mad.
Think of the people you know that annoy or plague you the most. Think of the worst people you can think of. Are they immigrants? Illegal aliens?
Probably not. Illegal aliens actually comprise a much lower per-capita percentage of crimes and criminals than native-born citizens represent. Most don’t want trouble. Most just want a better life than they had, and they get it here.
So, let’s try to think both in context of reality, but also think as if we’re all just humans trying to do our best. OK?
Liberty or Bust!
###